THE DOCTOR WHO RATINGS GUIDE: BY FANS, FOR FANS

Big Finish
The Infernal Nexus

Author Dave Stone Cover image
ISBN 1 903654 16 5
Published 2001

Synopsis: Bernice Summerfield has found herself on a probe-ship heading deep into the Problematic Heart of the galaxy. What she finds is Station Control. A place that exists, simultaniously, in four hundred and seventeen dimensions, a brawling, souk-like Nexus between every world that can, or has or ever will be. And one of those dimensions is Hell.


Reviews

A Review by Finn Clark 28/11/01

Hurm. I enjoyed it, but... Well, none of it's actually new, is it? It's like a bunch of other Stone books put into a blender - gratuitous OTT weirdness, sexually hyperactive queens of all they survey, cybernetically adapted superkillers, the characters, flamboyant brutality that rubs shoulders with flamboyant whimsy... all overlaid as usual with the deafeningly loud Dave Stone authorial voice. To like the book, you've got to like that. Me, I'm lucky. I do.

If I'd never read a Stone book before, I'd have adored this. The plot doesn't wait too long before making an appearance and eventually proves to be quite good. It's good, solid and twisty with actual surprises and a decent resolution, though after that there's still a good twenty-plus pages of back-to-reality tidying-up. The patented Dave Stone Appendix is thankfully: (a) brief, and (b) relevant to the characters of the novel.

Good stuff: the funkiest, um, spaceship in the world. Laugh-out-loud moments. Stone doing what he does best.

Downside: before the plot gets underway it feels like Dave Stone rambling on and not getting to anything much of a point. Normally I enjoy this, but for some reason my tolerance level was lower this time around. But more importantly, I've read all this before. It's not bad at all, but I could have saved £6.99 by rereading a selection of Stone's greatest hits instead. And the book's biggest surprise feels almost inevitable thirteen picoseconds later, whereupon it's business as usual.

But I enjoyed it, honest! :-)


The Infernal Autopilot by Robert Smith? 7/3/02

If the author bio is to be believed, Dave wrote The Infernal Nexus at the same time as The Slow Empire. This explains a few things. Not only are both books fairly similar, dealing with a large number of impossible-to-realise settings (a whole solar system of different planets in The Slow Empire, compared to 417 dimensions here, none of which are realised in any meaningful way), but Dave has continued to recycle whole chunks of text, not just from Ship of Fools and Heart of TARDIS, but from a book published at about the same time! I guess that's one way to deal with the increased workload in those months...

I've been meaning to comment on this before, but Dave has recycled the exact same ideas for about the fourth time now, so I can do it here. It's great that Dave Stone has a reputation for having ideas come fast and furious, and it's true that the idea about windows onto space being completely impractical and thus having cameras substitute for them to show a Star-Trekky view is a good one. But it was just as good an idea way back in Ship of Fools. And The Mary-Sue Extrusion. And The Slow Empire. And now The Infernal Nexus. Furthermore, Anji and Benny have the exact same thought processes about getting older and bodies becoming a bit slower as they move into their mid-thirties (which I presume is Dave Stone's age as well). It's one thing to have a reputation as a fast writer who can churn out decent books, but it's quite another to copy and paste text between books -- especially books that your target audience is highly likely to read and remember. Not only does this give off the impression that the author is desperately out of ideas, but it's unprofessional.

Anyway, to The Infernal Nexus itself, another TARGET length noveloid from Big Finish. I quite liked it. It's easily the second best Big Finish novel to date and might even surpass The Doomsday Manuscript if I gave the matter serious thought. We're nowhere near the Benny NAs, of course, but it's not without worth as well. This is also the best Dave Stone novel in quite some time, IMO.

I'm not sure why that is, honestly. I think it might be Benny and Jason, whom Dave seems born to write, unlike his recent struggles with the second, fourth and eighth Doctors. I'm glad that Big Finish didn't bring back Jason immediately, but I'm also glad that he's back now - it seems just the right length of time, even more so since it looks like the line won't be continuing. No one writes Jason better than Dave either. The Benny-Jason dialogue simply sparkles and their reunion is genuinely touching.

The 417 dimensions of nonsense are just there to give Dave a chance to do his usual schtick, but it's done reasonably well here, unlike the similar arbitrary weirdness of his last two novels. I think the novel's length helps enormously here, because Dave has to keep things tighter than he normally would and consequently there simply isn't time to get bored by all the usual tangents and asides, 60% of which are new material for his standup novel routine, now in its seventh year. We even get yet another race of pseudo-Sloathes, in the form of the Imps, which as best I can tell are simply an excuse for Dave to write yet more "Is good touchy feely wacky dialogue, yes?" Sometime in the future, archaeologists are going to piece together the quintessential Dave Stone novel, made up of pieces of all his previous novels. It probably won't be that different from anything we've had recently, but at least they'll go back to the Sloathes instead of all this Collector-Imp ridiculousness.

It's a bit odd to see Dr Rupert Gilhooly not only mentioned, but described in some detail, in the ridiculously wide text on the back cover, only for him to be reduced to a cameo in the opening sections. It's a bit of a pity he and Father Alsabalus didn't come along for the ride, but I suppose that would only have led to an irrelevant subplot and probably distracted us from the Benny and Jason stuff.

My biggest problem with The Slow Empire was that the footnotes were funny for a change, whereas the main text was rather dull. Here Dave's managed to balance both and add some restraint into the mix. What footnotes there are are great (especially the Vermicious Knids one), but they don't overpopulate the text either. I pity anyone with eye problems, though -- I didn't know font size could be that tiny! Special mention must go to Jason's "The Kiss of the Dragon Woman" at the end. You can just tell Dave wishes he'd written those bits of Beige Planet Mars, so to compensate we have the book we've just read resummarised in porno form. This is utterly, utterly hilarious and worth the price of admission alone.

The epilogue is fantastic. I honestly thought the books were pretty much ignoring each other, so to have actual consequences of The Squire's Crystal here is jarring (but welcome). Not as jarring as the revelation, of course. I'd like to talk about that in some detail, but I think I'll wait until The Glass Prison to see how it plays out. I'm quite keen to read the next one though, for the first time in Big Finish history, which is both great and a shame if indeed they are cancelling the line.

The Infernal Nexus is a snappy little novel. Dave Stone's autopilot drive is still engaged, but not nearly as much as his recent novels. I've decided I really like the new cover design even though it spoils a run of 87 straight books with white spines. My bank manager isn't too happy with this month's loan I've had to take out to afford the latest Big Finish novella, but the result is a tighter book than we've had from this author in a long time, so I win this month's tug-of-war with my financial institution. Recommended, unless your Doctor Who overdraft exceeds one audio and three books a month, in which case I won't be held responsible for the consequences.


A Review by John Seavey 10/3/03

This is another case of my own personal biases really helping me enjoy this book. I'm a huge Stone fan and a classic NAstalgic (including the Benny NAs, of which Stone was a major contributor and one of the three defining writers for the character of Bernice [1]), so for me this Big Finish Benny book was a little slice of heaven. In fact, if you love Dave Stone, you will unquestionably adore this book, as this is probably the most quintessentially "Dave Stone" book ever. I'm not sure whether he had wonderful editorial guidance, or none at all, but this book really frees him up to indulge in his own unique style of writing... and in a sense, this book is the culmination of all his earlier works.

[1] The other two being Paul Cornell and Justin Richards; although, to be honest, I'd actually rank Richards and Stone above Cornell in terms of influence, given that he hasn't written a book featuring the character since Oh No It Isn't!, and given that Stone and Richards created Jason and Brax, her two most important and enduring supporting cast members.

We get name-checks of the Sloathes, Planet X, the clockwork universe from Sky Pirates! as a whole (which apparently Benny either no longer remembers after all her brain-messings, or is being quite sarcastic about), an ARVID unit, and the Maze from one of his Judge Dredd novels... and, in fact, an explanation of sorts of the frequent repetitions of person and place names in his novels. According to Stone, "[Station Control, the setting of 'The Infernal Nexus'] was the epitome of its kind -- so much so, in fact, that versions of it spontaneously occurred in books written the universe over by a certain kind of brain-damaged writer who was responsive to the resonances of universes other than his own. And not as a desperate attempt to bump up the page-count by reusing old material from out-of-print books at all."

So there you go... The Infernal Nexus is the centerpiece of Stone's work, its... well, nexus, not to put too fine a point on it. If you love Stone, you simply must get this book.

There's also plenty to love for mere Stone-likers, too. Important stuff happens in this book to the Benny continuity -- we finally get the return of Jason, which if nothing else closes off the endless "This artifact might lead me to Jason!" plotlines. We get the revelation of Benny's pregnancy, which I knew about already because I'd read the back cover of The Glass Prison, but which is nonetheless well-and-sneakily-introduced here. We get threads tied up from The Dead Men Diaries, we get references to the classic Benny NAs (including references to Jason Kane's pornography, and the synopsis for the porno version of this very novel.) We get footnotes, we get funny aliens, we get imps, we get the whole package... oh, and for once, we don't get the sodding Fifth Axis, which I for one was heartily glad to see. They were getting to be like the Shredder in the 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' cartoon. :)

Oh, and we get a cover revamp, which is nice as that strange woman impersonating Benny was getting on my nerves. (Aside: Yes, I know and have always known that it was Lisa Bowerman... I was just getting sarky because she shouldn't have been on the cover in the first place. Benny has been shown several times on covers, and in point of fact is described in the Big Finish books differently from Lisa Bowerman. She should never have been used for the model for the covers.)

So, on the whole... if you're a fan of the old Benny books, and you want to buy just one of the new set, buy this one, and relive the Golden Age of Bernice Surprise Sumerfield. If you want to buy more than one, buy this one too, as it's the best of the lot so far. If you don't want to buy any, then don't. Nobody's forcing you to.