THE DOCTOR WHO RATINGS GUIDE: BY FANS, FOR FANS

The Companions
The Doctors

One's your favorite, another is interesting, another makes you wish you were watching Space: 1999... And now's your chance to say why each Doctor works or does not work for you. Be honest, be fair, and make your case for the good Doctors or their respective eras.

William Hartnell (9)
The First Doctor's era (2)
Patrick Troughton (9)
The Second Doctor's era (1)
Jon Pertwee (12)
The Third Doctor's era (6)
Tom Baker (10)
The Fourth Doctor's era (3)
Peter Davison (15)
The Fifth Doctor's era (6)
Colin Baker (22)
The Sixth Doctor's era (5)
Sylvester McCoy (10)
The Seventh Doctor's era (6)
Paul McGann (9)
The Eighth Doctor's era (1)
Christopher Eccleston (7)
The Ninth Doctor's era (1)
David Tennant (4)
The Tenth Doctor's era (1)
Matt Smith (1)
The Eleventh Doctor's era (0)